Report a Claim

Insurance claims are serious business.  If you need to make an insurance claim, contact the insurance carrier below either by telephone or their online claims center.

Make a Payment

If you are mailing a check, be sure to include your policy number with the check.  If you require assistance in making your payment or prefer to make an online payment, please contact the carrier directly using the information listed below.

Mouse Over for Details

Grange

Claims

800-422-0550

Grange Claim Center

Billing

800-332-3226

Grange Online Payment

Travelers

Claims

800-252-4633

Travelers Claim Center

Billing

One Tower Square

Hartford, CT 06183-8120

800-842-5075

Travelers Online Payment

Progressive

Claims

800-876-5581

Progressive Claim Center

Billing

800-332-3226

Progressive Online Payment

Personal Umbrella

800-564-1799

Personal Umbrella

Safeco

Claims

800-332-3226

Safeco Claim Center

Billing

800-332-3226

Safeco Online Payment

Allied

Claims

800-282-1446

Allied Claim Center

Billing

800-282-1446

Allied Online Payment

Titan — Victoria (Nationwide Insurance)

Claims

800-926-3168

Victoria Claim Service

Billing
800-888-8424

Vacant Express

800-310-3351

Vacant Express

Liberty Mutual

866-768-7614

Liberty Mutual

Selective

Claims

800-777-9656

Selective Claim Center

Billing

800-332-3226

Selective Online Payment

Foremost

Claims

800-274-7865 (Auto)

800-527-3907 (All but Auto)

Foremost Claim Center

Billing

855-325-2455

Foremost Online Payment

Dairyland Auto & Motorcycle (Sentry Insurance)

Claims

800-338-2487

Dairyland Claim Center

Billing
800-227-0201 (Auto)
800-526-4252 (Cycle)

Hagerty

800-747-5348

Hagerty